Skip to main content

Human smuggling: Crackdown goes too far: Report




While Canadians aren’t thrilled to see boatloads of people — including both economic migrants and genuine refugees — turning up here seeking asylum, as 492 Tamils from Sri Lanka did this summer, does Ottawa need to slap them in jail for a year, deny them permanent residency and cut their health coverage to tell the world that we won’t be played for patsies?



That’s the question Parliament must ask as it studies Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s tough new crackdown on human smuggling. The Preventing Human Smugglers from Abusing Canada’s Immigration System Act that Public Safety Minister Vic Toews unveiled Thursday warrants critical study before it is rushed into law.



In effect, the bill would create a less worthy category of refugee — people whom Canada’s public safety minister deems to have arrived in a “human smuggling event.” They would pay a heavy price for it.



The vast majority of refugee claimants arrive in Canada by air or by land. The few who arrive by sea, as did the Sun Sea migrants from Sri Lanka, would face far harsher treatment under the bill.



They would be held in mandatory detention for up to a year, or until officials decide their claims. They would have fewer rights of appeal.



Even if they were accepted as refugees, they would not be allowed to apply for permanent residency for five years, sponsor family members or travel abroad. Ottawa could also “reassess” them at any point to see whether they could be shipped home or still need protection. And they would get less health coverage.



All this appears to fly in the face of Canada’s moral obligation to treat refugee claimants equitably, however they get here. It amounts to “attacking the victim and not the criminals,” as New Democrat MP Olivia Chow pointed out. Parliament needs to think this through.



Other elements of the new policy are less problematic, insofar as they target the smuggler kingpins who profiteer from human misery.



Canadian law already provides for $1 million fines and/or life in prison for people who smuggle more than 10 passengers. But in future judges would mete out mandatory prison terms ranging from three to 10 years, depending on the number smuggled and such “aggravating factors” as whether the trade was for profit, part of a crime syndicate, and risky for passengers. There are stiffer penalties, too, for ship owners who skirt the rules.



Some of this would tie judges’ hands. It remains to be seen whether it would deter smugglers, result in more convictions, or even scare off migrants.



Canada processed 34,000 refugee claims last year. Precious few arrived by boat. The real solution lies in persuading countries such as Thailand (where the Sun Sea was registered) to break up the smuggling rings before boats leave port.



Canadians don’t want to be played for fools. But let’s target the profiteers and show some compassion for the people they prey on. This bill needs some sober second thought. – (Toronto Star)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

In abrupt turnaround, Olympus admits it hid losses

Japan's Olympus admitted on Tuesday it hid losses on securities investments dating back two decades, bowing to weeks of pressure to explain a series of baffling transactions that have put the future of the firm in doubt. The revelations by the 92-year-old company appear to vindicate ex-CEO Michael Woodford, who has staged a campaign since being sacked on October 14 to force the firm to come clean on nearly $1.5 billion in questionable payments. Olympus President Shuichi Takayama blamed Tsuyoshi Kikukawa, who quit as president and chairman on October 26, Vice-President Hisashi Mori and internal auditor Hideo Yamada for the cover-up, saying he would consider criminal complaints against them. The admission after weeks of denials shocked investors, sending shares in the endoscope and camera maker skidding almost 30 percent and prompting the biggest non-Japanese shareholder to demand the replacement of the entire board. "Ignorance is no defense," said Jo...

Last year's iPhones are destroying Samsung's new Galaxy S9 flagship smartphone - Bench Mark Results

Samsung announced the Galaxy S9 and Galaxy S9+, the latest entries in its flagship line of smartphones, at Barcelona's Mobile World Congress — but benchmark results are awkwardly showing the devices scoring significantly lower than many of their competitors. Benchmarks are synthetic tests that give numeric, quantifiable results. They are generally applications programmed to make the devices' systems-on-a-chip (SoC) run a series of tasks and determine how long it takes them to complete. AnandTech is a site that specialises in running rigorous tests like these, and its early findings on Samsung's latest devices are curious to say the least— particularly compared to the latest iPhones, Qualcomm's Snapdragon 845 — which will power most of the Android flagships this year — and even Samsung's own Galaxy S8 from last year. In a number of tests — such as web browsing, writing, data manipulation, and photo editing — the Galaxy S9's Exynos 9810 consistently deliv...

Microsoft nears $8.5 billion Skype buy in web shift

Microsoft is close to buying internet telephony network Skype in an $8.5 billion deal, a source familiar with the situation said, as it seeks to regain ground on growing rivals such as Google. Buying the loss-making but popular Skype would underline Microsoft's need to gain new customers and platforms for its software as smartphones and tablets explode in popularity. Skype, which allows people to make calls at no charge, would also give Microsoft a foothold in potentially the lucrative video-conferencing market as global businesses seeking to reduce expenditure shift to lower-cost ways of communicating. Microsoft has already put more energy and resources into mobile and internet technologies as the use of PCs, which underpin its Windows and Office franchise, is under threat. This change was starkly illustrated last year when Apple's portfolio of coveted consumer goods propelled it past Microsoft to become the world's most valuable technology company. The maker of iPhones an...